Maintenance of garden wall

A garden wall in the scheme is deteriorating and needs maintenance. The Trustees are saying that the owner of the unit is responsible as it is his garden. The owner is saying that the Body Corporate is responsible as the garden is common property.

First we will have to check the plans and the rules to see the status of the garden.

It generally is common property even though the owner of the unit is the only one who has access to it.  And common property maintenance is the responsibility of the Body Corporate.

If the plans indicate that the garden is an EUA then the Body Corporate will also be responsible for maintenance of the wall.

If the garden area is an EUA in terms of the rules we will have to look at the wording of the rules.  If the area is only described as a garden then the Body Corporate will be responsible for maintenance (if the rules do not make the owner responsible for maintenance).  If the rules state that the owner is responsible for maintenance to the garden but the rules state nothing about the wall being included in the EUA then the Body Corporate will be responsible for the wall and the owner for the garden.

It is only when the wall is specifically included in the EUA in terms of the rules and the rules specify that the owner is responsible for maintenance of the EUA – then the owner will be responsible and not the Body Corporate.