Leak between two Sections – Who pays for the resultant damage to the unit below?

There was a leak from the unit above into the unit below, and now the owner above refuses to pay for the resultant damage to the unit below.

The STSM Act apportions maintenance responsibility to either the owner of a section or the Body Corporate

Section 3. (1) A body corporate must perform the functions entrusted to it by or under this Act or the rules, and such functions include—

(l) to maintain all the common property and to keep it in a state of good and serviceable repair;

Section13. (1) An owner must—

(c)repair and maintain his or her section in a state of good repair and, in respect of an exclusive use area, keep it in a clean and neat condition;

So the owner above is responsible for fixing the leak in their section

And the owner below is responsible for fixing the damage in their section

There is no common property involved, and the Body Corporate therefore doesn’t have to pay for anything

The owner below however, has a claim against the owner above (if the insurance company does not pay for the resultant damage)

Should the owner above refuse to pay for the resultant damage, then the owner below can lodge a dispute with CSOS

CSOS Act

Section 39 Prayers for relief

(6) In respect of works pertaining to private areas and common areas—

(b) an order requiring the relevant person—

  • to carry out specified repairs, or have specified repairs made; or
  • to pay the applicant an amount fixed by the adjudicator as reimbursement for repairs carried out or to be carried out in respect of the property by the applicant;