Our rules state that no pets are allowed. How do we deal with “emotional support animals”?
Normally you would have to look at the Schemes approved rules – approved by special resolution and by CSOS, but in this case the rules state “No pets”.
So we have to refer to the Prescribed Conduct Rules (PCR) – and specifically PCR 1
Keeping of animals, reptiles and birds
- (1) The owner or occupier of a section must not, without the trustees’ written consent, which must not be unreasonably withheld, keep an animal, reptile or bird in a section or on the common property.
- An owner or occupier suffering from a disability and who reasonably requires a guide, hearing or assistance dog must be considered to have the trustees’ consent to keep that animal in a section and to accompany it on the common property.
- The trustees may provide for any reasonable condition in regard to the keeping of an animal, reptile or bird in a section or on the common property.
- The trustees may withdraw any consent if the owner or occupier of a section breaches any condition imposed in terms of sub-rule (3).
There is no definition of what a “disability” is considered to be. And the PCR refers to “guide, hearing or assistance”. It can be argued that that does not include therapy or emotional support animals. The PCR also specifically refers to dogs only – so it can be argued that this does not include any other animal.
It is also very easy to get a “doctor’s note” stating that the animal is indeed an emotional support animal.
The Trustees should tread lightly in these instances as it is clearly the wish of the owners to not have animals in the scheme. Based on the above the owner will not have automatic approval for an emotional support animal – especially if it is for instance a cat.
The suggestion would be that if the Trustees refuse the animal based on the approved rules then the owner should try CSOS for relief as they will look at all arguments before making an order.
